On March 23, 1775 Patrick Henry made a famous speech. Would he repeat it today?

Image result for patrick henry

In the face of COVID-19, one wonders if Patrick Henry would have repeated today the sentiment that he uttered before the second Virginia convention on 23 March 1775.

Why stand we here idle? What is it that gentlemen wish? What would they have? Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery? Forbid it, Almighty God! I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty or give me death!

Admittedly, Mr. Henry was speaking to an audience that was not yet held in the intellectual thralldom of the scientists and statisticians who reign supreme over the denizens of the twenty-first century.

Nonetheless, he was speaking to an audience over which George III reigned and, at least from the history books I read, he appeared to have been quite formidable in his own way. Fortunately for America, British Regulars were a little easier to spot for colonial marksmen than is the invisible enemy that presently invades our shores.

As sympathetic as I am towards my own health and especially towards the health of the vulnerable elderly and those with underlying health conditions, it does make me shudder a little that the right to free assembly and public worship appears to have vanished almost overnight.

Thankfully, none of us need entertain any suspicions that the current suspension of political and religious liberty is the result of an overseas potentate exercising despotic power through grossly unreasonable taxes on our tea!

Image result for boston tea party

No need to suspect covert and nefarious forces at work orchestrating an attack on the principle of self-governance and local sovereignty that is the hallmark of American patriots. Although a foreign flu appears to have squelched massive pro-Democracy protests in Hong Kong, it is we ourselves through our own elected leaders who have voluntarily set aside our liberty.

Image result for george iii

Let us be grateful that George III never thought of using something like the Coronovirus to suppress public meetings in 1775.

After all, life is more important than liberty is it not?

What was Patrick Henry thinking?

Posted in America, classical education, Custom, enlightenment | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

The Samaritan Woman at Jacob’s Well: Who Were Those Five Husbands?

Image result for samaritan woman at jacob's well

[I could not resist reposting this – the original may be found here with a number of great comments!]

The Gospel for the third Sunday of Lent offers a special little gem for the classically minded church-goer. As Jesus is speaking to the Samaritan woman at Jacob’s Well, He tells her that the water in the well will only bring a limited satisfaction.

Whosoever drinketh of this water, shall thirst again; but he that shall drink of the water that I will give him, shall not thirst for ever: But the water that I will give him, shall become in him a fountain of water, springing up into life everlasting. The woman saith to him: Sir, give me this water, that I may not thirst, nor come hither to draw.

I am no Scripture scholar, but it’s clear to me that the water that Our Lord is speaking about here is not some kind of physical or sensible water. He is not speaking about H2O.  He is clearly referring to something else; something like the waters of Baptism. Or perhaps he is referring to the gift of faith itself under the figure of water. It is through Faith that the believer springs up to life everlasting.

Image result for baptismal water

The Samaritan woman does not necessarily understand this, but nonetheless desires this special water. But then Our Lord makes this rather strange request:

Jesus saith to her: Go, call thy husband, and come hither. The woman answered, and said: I have no husband. Jesus said to her: Thou hast said well, I have no husband: For thou hast had five husbands: and he whom thou now hast, is not thy husband.

My knowledge of the customs of the Samaritans is limited. How is it that the woman at Jacob’s well had five husbands? Perhaps each husband successively died? Either that or this woman was a sort of scriptural pre-cursor to Elizabeth Taylor?

Image result for elizabeth taylor young

In addition, the shocking revelation of the number of husbands that this Samaritan woman has had sort of covers up what appears to be a strange request by Our Lord in the first place. Why does he say “Go, call thy husband”? Why do we suddenly need the woman’s husband?

But the answer to this particular question is not quite as interesting to the hearer as the simple revelation that this woman has had five husbands!

It’s not everyday that one meets a man who has had five wives, much less a woman who has had five husbands!

I confess I find it scarcely credible that anyone could have that many spouses.

Now I remember that when interpreting scripture one is always supposed to start with the literal meaning. The other figurative meanings have their foundation in the literal meaning.

Image result for senses of scripture

So I am ready to simply take Our Lord’s word for it that this woman did in fact have five husbands. She, on the other hand, appears to be very impressed by His knowledge of this and immediately says,

Sir, I perceive that thou art a prophet.

And later she tells her fellow townspeople,

Come, and see a man who has told me all things whatsoever I have done. Is not he the Christ?

So, again, I suppose we need to simply assent to the simple fact that the Samaritan woman has had five husbands. Perhaps her husbands were each a little like the water in Jacob’s well; stagnant, dull and unsatisfying. Hence she keeps going back to the “well” to draw up another one.

But I don’t think we should be satisfied with only the literal meaning of the Gospel in this instance. Five husbands are just too unusual to let it pass that easily.

Here are two figurative accounts of these five husbands that I find very satisfying.

The first is explained by the Catholic apologist Gary Michuta  who points out the fascinating fact that the Samaritan woman’s “matrimonial history” has an uncanny “parallel in the religious history of Samaria” itself .

Samaria was once part of the northern kingdom of Israel, which had broken off from the Davidic Kingdom…The king of Assyria brought pagans into Samaria to settle there (1 Kings 17:24).

Interestingly enough, 1 Kings 17:30-31 tells us there were five groups that settled there, each worshipping their own pagan gods: The Babylonians worshipped Marduk; the men of Cuth worshipped Nergal; the men of Avva worshipped Nibhaz and Tartak; the men of Sepharvaim worshipped their city gods; and King Hadad worshipped Anath.

Even though the Israelites were joined in covenant to the one true God, they intermarried with these foreigners and adopted their worship and practices. This is why the Jews wouldn’t have anything in common with Samaritans — because their assimilation with these pagans had defiled them. Samaria, like the woman at the well, had five husbands and was estranged from her true husband.

Now this is very revealing! Scales are falling from my eyes!

It makes abundant sense that Our Lord was referring to these false gods as husbands. How often does Our Lord compare his relation to the church through the image of the bridegroom? Christ is the husband of His bride the church. So of course, the five husbands might fittingly refer to Samaria’s unfortunate “marriages” to five false gods.

For our second figurative interpretation let us turn to Saint Augustine. It was through reading his book On the Interpretation of Scripture , that I first gained a sense for the many layers of wisdom contained in the Scriptures. It was there that I learned the principle rule of interpretation, namely the “rule of charity.” Scripture should not be interpreted in a way that contradicts any other part of Scripture. Or more positively, we ought to be open to reasonable interpretations of scripture as long as they do not contradict other doctrines or interpretations that have already been set forth.  Additionally, if I remember correctly, Saint Augustine seems to have a particular fondness towards making sense of numbers in scripture. I know there are some who downplay numbers in the Bible – and I suppose many get carried away with their numerological interpretations – but if examining numbers seriously in scripture was good enough for Augustine, then it is also good enough for me!

Image result for saint augustine

So here is what Saint Augustine says about the five husbands (among other things).

Jesus seeing that the woman did not understand, and wishing to enlighten her, says, Call your husband; i.e. apply your understanding. For when the life is well-ordered, the understanding governs the soul itself, pertaining to the soul. For though it is indeed nothing else than the soul, it is at the same time a certain part of the soul.

Now that is a shock isn’t it? Saint Augustine appears to be suggesting that the rational ability that we have, the understanding, is fittingly called “husband” by Our Lord.

I am certain that Saint Augustine meant no offense with his reference to the understanding as the husband. I think he means something like what St Paul said when he says,

But I would have you know, that the head of every man is Christ; and the head of the woman is the man; and the head of Christ is God.

The head, of course, is often associated with thinking and I think it is safe to call it the seat of the understanding. Is that a safe assertion?

And so we needn’t dismiss Saint Augustine’s interpretation as merely an interpretation coming out of the patriarchal mindset that he undoubtedly had inherited through no fault of his own.

Rather it would appear, according to Saint Augustine, that beyond any actual husbands that the woman had, he was more concerned with the “husband” that is none other than the understanding part of the woman’s soul. Call that husband.

But more importantly,Saint Augustine gives us an insight into the nature of the human soul. The “well-ordered” soul might be seen as a sort of marriage between the understanding part of the soul and the soul itself. In other words, the soul might be said to have a part which governs, and this part we call the husband.

He continues:

And this very part of the soul which is called the understanding and the intellect, is itself illuminated by a light superior to itself. Such a Light was talking with the woman; but in her there was not understanding to be enlightened.

It seems to me that there is a sort of proportion here. As the understanding governs and instructs a person, so too should Christ Himself govern and instruct the understanding.

In other words, Christ is the bridegroom of the soul. Christ is the husband of the understanding soul.

Our Lord then, as it were, says, I wish to enlighten, and there is not one to be enlightened; Call your husband, i. e. apply your understanding, through which you must be taught, by which {you must be} governed.

Image result for christ the teacher

And now you are thinking, “What about those five husbands?”

Without missing the cue,Saint Augustine responds,

The five former husbands may be explained as the five senses, thus: a man before he has the use of his reason, is entirely under the government of his bodily senses. Then reason comes into action; and from that time forward he is capable of entertaining ideas, and is either under the influence of truth or error.

We are either under the governance of our reason, or under the governance of our senses. The senses of course, in a broader sense,  also include the so-called sensitive appetites otherwise known as the passions or the emotions.

We are either governed by our reason or by our passions.

And so our understanding soul, that which ought to govern, is called “husband” by our Lord. But when we are ruled by our appetites, then we have unsatisfying and even “dull” husbands. The senses are not quite as keen as the intellect. No wonder we would marry one after another.

Image result for the five sense

And when Our Lord says,

“and he whom thou now hast, is not thy husband.”

He now refers to an even worse husband than the dull senses or passions. He is referring to the “husband” who is Error. Error might be called an “adulterer”, because the understanding soul ought to be wedded to the truth, the understanding soul ought to be wedded to Christ.

It clearly follows what Saint Augustine says next:

The woman had been under the influence of error, which error was not her lawful husband, but an adulterer. Wherefore our Lord says, Put away that adulterer which corrupts thee, and call your husband, that you may understand Me.

Posted in Augustine, Catena Aurea, classical education | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Learning in Virus Time

Image result for coronavirus students classrooms

In a sermon delivered in the Fall of 1939 titled Learning in Wartime, C.S. Lewis asserts,

every Christian who comes to a university must at all times face a question compared with which the questions raised by the war are relatively unimportant. He must ask himself how it is right, or even psychologically possible, for creatures who are every moment advancing either to Heaven or to hell to spend any fraction of the little time allowed them in this world on such comparative trivialities as literature or art, mathematics or biology

Now I can only guess about the anxiety and feelings of dread that Lewis was addressing among the student body at Oxford at that time. Bombs had not yet dropped on London as they would a year later during the German Blitzkrieg of 1940. I don’t know how his sermon was received at St Mary’s Church that particular evening in the Fall of ’39,  but I regret to say that my own sense for self-preservation would probably have precluded me from sticking around to the end of it should the bombs have started dropping a little earlier.

Image result for cs lewis learning in wartime

Nonetheless, I wonder if he might have delivered the same sermon during the virus of 2020?

Granted there must be a difference between the feelings of those who faced possible enlistment, and consequently imminent death, and the feelings of a people whose confrontation with death and mortality is largely based on screen-induced fear and media-driven panic. Nonetheless, I think it is safe to say that C.S. Lewis would surely be empathetic with the terrible dread and anxiety of present-day thinking Americans, even despite its irrational basis.

I admit it. When the financial markets plunge, when nations quarantine their citizens, when the diocese of Rome cancels all public Masses, when hand sanitizer and Kleenex are flying off the shelves, I can’t think of a time when the study of Latin and Greek and Euclidean geometry seemed more insignificant (except for maybe here). I can’t remember a time when teaching the liberal arts, the seven arts of the Quadrivium and the Trivium seemed, well…more trivial.

As Lewis asks his students,

why should we – indeed how can we – continue to take an interest in these placid occupations when the lives of our friends and the liberties of Europe are in the balance? Is it not like fiddling while Rome burns?

Yea, learning the liberal arts at the present time is in fact quite like fiddling while Rome burns! No, even more, it is not like fiddling… it is fiddling.

Thirty years ago I suppose I was thinking there was still enough time to spread liberal education throughout the land. There was still enough time, that is, to stop and put to rout the forces of modern barbarism.

I told myself that even a handful of classically minded teachers could affect the entire nation. If 12 apostles could spread Christ’s gospel throughout the world, then certainly several hundred liberally educated teachers could transform a single nation!

Student by student, family by family, what with the laws of exponential expansion and the magic of liberal education, I would participate in making small ripples which, though parochial as they were, would in a matter of a decade or so increase to a tsunami-sized deluge, transforming and disposing the hearts and minds of thousands and even millions towards an enthusiastic embrace of  Western Civilization!

Oh well, thirty years later here we are. Standing on the brink of collapse. Brought to this pathetic state by a mere virus. Reduced by something akin to the common cold! So much for hic, haec, hoc and qui, quae, quod!

What is the point of learning now? My efforts and those of a great many others do not appear to have transformed the culture. What a colossal waste of time to teach students how to conjugate a verb and decline a noun.

Arma virumque cano….whatever!

Image result for virgils tomb

But I ask myself “What would C.S. Lewis do?” “How would he respond to my despair?”

C.S. Lewis: Pipe-Smoking Biography | Smokingpipes.com

 

Well, I think I know. He would say,  No! This way of thinking is nothing but Tomfoolery!  As if the primary purpose of pursuing a liberal education was to transform the culture in the first place! Hogwash! Yes, maybe liberal education is part of a solution for those who wish to transform the culture, but how insulting it is to assert that this is the purpose of such an education.

He would go on to point out that the present calamity that is the virus of 2020 “creates no absolutely new situation,” as neither did World War II.

The war creates no absolutely new situation: it simply aggravates the permanent human situation so that we can no longer ignore it. Human life has always been lived on the edge of a precipice. Human culture has always had to exist under the shadow of something infinitely more important than itself. If men had postponed the search for knowledge and beauty until they were secure the search would never have begun. We are mistaken when we compare war with “normal life”. Life has never been normal.

When precisely, I ask, is a person supposed to pursue the excellence of soul for which he was created? We are not like the insects who as Lewis says, first seek

the material welfare and security of the hive, and presumably they have their reward. Men are different. They propound mathematical theorems in beleaguered cities, conduct metaphysical arguments in condemned cells, make jokes on the scaffold, discuss the last new poem while advancing to the walls of Quebec, and comb their hair at Thermopylae.

Like Archimedes in his beleaguered Syracuse and Boethius in his cell and Thomas More on the scaffold and James Wolfe on the Plains of Abraham and the noble Spartans who resisted the Barbarian at Thermopylae, we should not cease from the practice of truth, beauty, and goodness just because our own civilization appears to be collapsing.

Posted in catholic education, Christendom, classical education, education, Latin, Liberal Arts, liberal education | Tagged , , , , , | 3 Comments

Why I do not want to be the King of Scotland

I’m not so certain that I want to be king of Scotland anymore.

After reading The Tragedy of Macbeth with my students, I am having a difficult time shaking off a sense that life is meaningless when worldly ambition is the governing principle.

In Act II, King Duncan has been dispatched “to heaven or to hell,” by his own kith and kin- nay more even by his host and hostess who are now able to supplant him as king and Queen of Scotland. One would think that this would be enough to bring some kind of pleasure even if we grant it a guilty one. But Lady Macbeth dispels any doubt about this pleasure in Act III,

LADY MACBETH
Nought’s had, all’s spent,
Where our desire is got without content:
Tis safer to be that which we destroy
Than by destruction dwell in doubtful joy…

 

And then Macbeth himself confirms the sentiment saying,

 

MACBETH
…better be with the dead,
Whom we, to gain our peace, have sent to peace,
Than on the torture of the mind to lie
In restless ecstasy. Duncan is in his grave;
After life’s fitful fever he sleeps well;
Treason has done his worst: nor steel, nor poison,
Malice domestic, foreign levy, nothing,
Can touch him further.

 

But you might say

 

You
Langley, you are mistaken about the intent of the author here. Of course Macbeth and Lady Macbeth are not content, of course they are miserable. They have guilty consciences! This is another play about guilty consciences…just like that other one…what was it…er…

 

Do you mean Aeschylus’ The Eumenides?  I spoke about that play here if you’re interested.

 

You
Yes that’s it. You are simply repeating now what you said then. Shakespeare and Aeschylus both attest to the reality of conscience. They both attest to the reality of the natural law. They both attest that crimes against nature will not go unpunished….especially regicide!

 

Well, that’s a good point. I had failed to make that connection. I suppose Shakespeare’s Lady Macbeth does remind me a bit of Lady Agamemnon or rather Clytemnestra.

But Clytemnestra was far more certain of herself and less remorseful. I could never see Clytemnestra walking in her sleep uttering things like,
LADY MACBETH
Yet here’s a spot.

Doctor
Hark! she speaks. I will set down what comes
from her, to satisfy my remembrance the more
strongly.

LADY MACBETH
Out, damned spot! out, I say!—One: two: why,
then, ’tis time to do’t.—Hell is murky!—Fie, my
lord, fie! a soldier, and afeard? What need we
fear who knows it, when none can call our power
to account?—Yet who would have thought the old
man to have had so much blood in him?

Doctor
Do you mark that?

LADY MACBETH
The thane of Fife had a wife; where is she now?—
What, will these hands ne’er be clean?—No more o’
that, my lord, no more o’ that: you mar all with
this starting.

She’s on the verge of a mental breakdown. Lady Macbeth is not so tough after all, even though she made herself appear so in the first act, when she said:
LADY MACBETH
…Come, you spirits
That tend on mortal thoughts, unsex me here,
And fill me from the crown to the toe top-full
Of direst cruelty! make thick my blood;
Stop up the access and passage to remorse,
That no compunctious visitings of nature
Shake my fell purpose, nor keep peace between
The effect and it! Come to my woman’s breasts,
And take my milk for gall, you murdering ministers,
Wherever in your sightless substances
You wait on nature’s mischief! Come, thick night,
And pall thee in the dunnest smoke of hell,
That my keen knife see not the wound it makes,
Nor heaven peep through the blanket of the dark,
To cry ‘Hold, hold!’

Clytemnestra would not have said that. I suppose she had ten years to brood and plan her husband’s murder. Perhaps over the decade while Agamemnon was fighting in Troy her blood had the time it needed to congeal making any such speech unnecessary.

Nonetheless, aside from the teaching about conscience and crimes against nature that we find in Macbeth, aside from his poignant portrayals of a man and a woman who are driven deeper and deeper into acts of deception and violence- and ultimately even to madness in the case of Lady Macbeth- Shakespeare is adding a lesson for us about worldly ambition.

If success in this world is the principal objective of a person’s life then “life is but a walking shadow, a poor player, that frets and struts his hour upon the stage, and then is heard no more.”

The ambitious man is a “walking shadow,” that is, his life is dim, empty and insubstantial.

Why?

 

Because, after a while the ambitious man will undoubtedly consider himself as a “poor player” on the stage; he will consider himself as one who has the appearance of being something that he is not. He will see that his life is that of one fretting and strutting for an hour upon the stage but soon he will be heard from no more. Other actors will soon take his place.

Time itself reminds us all of the potential meaninglessness of life. Each day passes much like the day before in the endless succession of tomorrows. All of our yesterdays are non-existent except in memory. And fools, those who esteemed themselves as something they were not, have simply returned unto the dust from which they came. For the ambitious life sometimes, if not often, is suddenly cut short without a proper ending – like a story told by an idiot.

Tomorrow, and tomorrow, and tomorrow,
Creeps in this petty pace from day to day,
To the last syllable of recorded time;
And all our yesterdays have lighted fools
The way to dusty death. Out, out, brief candle!
Life’s but a walking shadow, a poor player,
That struts and frets his hour upon the stage,
And then is heard no more. It is a tale
Told by an idiot, full of sound and fury,
Signifying nothing.
Posted in classical education, Literature, Shakespeare, Temptation, truth for its own sake | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Sin is first in the will: a brief lesson in morality from Lady Macbeth

Of all the authors we should compel our students to read, surely no one is so foolhardy as to demand a reason for reading Shakespeare.

I can forgive the one who asks,

Why should students read Aeschylus?

Image result for aeschylus

Or

Why do you force them to read Thucydides?

But this is only because these authors are ancient Greeks and therefore might appear (at first glance) to be so remote, so out-dated and outmoded that perhaps devouring time has blunted their relevance.

Of course, nothing could be further from the truth!

Thankfully, Shakespeare still appears to be among the authors with whose works a more than passing familiarity is still deemed a sine qua non for the one who dares to think himself educated.

Notice the phrase “passing familiarity.” I chose those words very carefully because that is an exact characterization of my own knowledge of Shakespeare. Embarrassing, but no matter how many times I read his plays, I am only able to tell you about the very one that I happen to be reading at the moment. Sadly this disqualifies me from the prestigious ranks of Shakespeare scholars- a group I admire beyond words.

Nonetheless, as I am currently reading The Tragedy of Macbeth, I can’t help thinking that reading Shakespeare is a fantastic way to introduce high school students to the subtleties of the moral act.

Take this for example. In Act I Scene VII, Lady Macbeth has managed to cajole and persuade Macbeth to “screw up his courage to the sticking-place” and resolve to kill his kinsman and his king, the unfortunate and doomed Duncan.

Image result for macbeth

Macbeth says, betokening his interior resolution and interior purpose,

I am settled, and bend up each corporal agent to this terrible feat. Away and mock the time with fairest show: False face must hide what the false heart doth know.

Shakespeare teaches us with poignancy about the difference between the internal and the external; the inner act and the outer act. He teaches us that sin is first in the will as Saint Augustine taught in the fourth century.

Saint Thomas Aquinas quotes Augustine in his Summa,

Augustine says that “it is by the will that we sin, and that we behave aright.” Therefore moral good and evil are first in the will.

This is a profound teaching. It is not the external act that condemns us. It is not the outer sin that confounds us so much as the act of the will whereby we resolve to commit the outer sin. And this Lady Macbeth affirms in Act II. After having drugged Duncan’s guards, she fails to commit the murder herself,

Macbeth. [Within] Who’s there? what, ho!

Lady Macbeth. Alack, I am afraid they have awaked,
And ’tis not done. The attempt and not the deed
Confounds us. Hark! I laid their daggers ready;
He could not miss ’em. Had he not resembled
My father as he slept, I had done’t.
[Enter MACBETH]
My husband!

Frightened by every noise, Lady Macbeth gives evidence of a guilty conscience even though she had not the strength to carry out the ghastly deed outwardly that she had already committed inwardly. It doesn’t matter. She is a murderess.

Image result for lady macbeth

The attempt and not the deed Confounds us.

It is the attempt, the intention, the will settled on evil that condemns us.

This is not to say that the outward act doesn’t matter. No, in fact, the external action adds and increases the evil – but seemingly only in degree, not in kind. Thus St. Thomas explains,

… every inclination or movement is perfected by attaining its end or reaching its term. Wherefore the will is not perfect, unless it be such that, given the opportunity, it realizes the operation. But if this prove impossible, as long as the will is perfect, so as to realize the operation if it could; the lack of perfection derived from the external action, is simply involuntary.

Shakespeare helps us to understand what our Lord is speaking about when he says in Matthew,

You have heard that it was said to them of old: Thou shalt not kill. And whosoever shall kill shall be in danger of the judgment. But I say to you, that whosoever is angry with his brother, shall be in danger of the judgment….You have heard that it was said to them of old: Thou shalt not commit adultery. But I say to you, that whosoever shall look on a woman to lust after her, hath already committed adultery with her in his heart.

If anything, Christ came not to overturn the law with regard to the exterior act, the outward man. Our external actions and behavior are important, and there were roughly two thousand years of Old Testament history to prove that.

But Our Lord appears to be even more interested in the interior man than the exterior man. He is interested more in what is on the inside than what is on the outside; Perhaps the external is really for the sake of the internal?

Could it be that Our Lord is really after our souls?

Image result for good shepherd

Posted in aeschylus, Augustine, catholic education, classical education, Literature, Shakespeare, Temptation | Tagged , , , , | 1 Comment

The Priest: Privileged Witness of the Reality of Grace Present in the World

On this, the eve of the Epiphany, with the Christ Child still lying in the manger, a great many Catholics everywhere are hoping and praying for a year of renewed grace. And, of course, with the turn of the secular calendar, the dawn of 2020, who is there that doesn’t share in a renewed sense of hopeful optimism that our beloved Church is in for better times?

Image result for wise men nativity painting"

But what is the core of our hope? In light of the last couple of seasons that have left many of the faithful more than a little perplexed, and certainly more than a little dispirited, where is the grace of God?

My wife and I received a Christmas letter from a dear friend, a priest, that, though somewhat somber in tone, is reminiscent of the plaintive cry of the psalmist, and it beautifully reminded us that God’s grace is ubiquitous and at work everywhere if we only have the eyes to see.

Image result for psalmist"

With his permission, I have published his letter here, with minimal redactions, not wishing to make any problems for him should his identity be known. I think readers of this blog will be similarly moved, if not to tears, at least moved to a deeper vision of the actions of God’s grace among the faithful. His letter inspired me with more profound reasons for hope!

Last year I did not send out a Christmas letter and one correspondent complained. So this year I will do my best. It will not be easy. Last year was the year of Theodore McCarrick and Archbishop Viganó, but this year has been the year of the Amazon Synod and Pachamama. Evidently, things are not getting any better.

I am left wondering sometimes if ignorance is not indeed bliss. One day, during the Amazon Synod, at daily Mass I asked for a show of hands of those who had even heard of the Amazon Synod. One lady raised her hand. There was another occasion on which I made mention of the Amazon Synod and my interlocutor thought I was referring to Amazon.com. Maybe he thought that ‘synod’ referred to some new electronic gadget.

Image result for amazon synod"

In the past, I wrote about my life of the priesthood. … In any case, sometimes I think I am preaching to those who are “distracted from distraction by distraction,” if they are even present in the church at Mass. Meanwhile up above, madmen seem intent upon burning down the house and nobody pays attention.

In times of such darkness and confusion Advent makes too much sense. “Come, Lord Jesus, do not delay.” In the words of the Didache, “Let grace come, and let this world pass away.” My apologies to all of you who have children, but I actually have many more than you, of all ages, some older than myself. Age doesn’t matter, they are still capable of sobbing uncontrollably.

“Let grace come” and it does. That is the inexpressible privilege of the priest, to stand at the altar when grace comes down from heaven, every time, and to sit in the confessional where grace touches the soul of man. The priest, if he has eyes to see, is the privileged witness of the reality of grace still present in the world, still trying to break through like the grass pushing through the cracks in the hard paving stones of city sidewalks, paving stones that reflect the hardness of human hearts. Grace is more powerful. Even if the new life is so fragile and delicate as a little baby lying in a manger it is always the sign of hope. Even though Herod rages, God has not abandoned his people.

Image result for nativity scene wise men painting"

So long as this world lasts, we rightly celebrate Christmas, even in the worst times, because grace is always born anew. When one person says ‘yes’ to the grace of God, that ‘yes’, which mirrors the ‘yes’ of Mary, weighs more in the balance than all the darkness and confusion combined. It is not about changing the world, doomed to destruction, one person at a time, it is about giving glory to God in the midst of the deepest darkness, like St. Maximillian Kolbe. After Christmas comes St. Stephen.

“Truth is sprung out of the earth: and justice looked down from heaven. For the Lord will give goodness: and our earth shall yield her fruit.”

Image result for grass breaking through concrete"

Posted in Augustine, beauty, Christmas, Feasts | Tagged , , , , | 5 Comments

As Long as Catholics Continue Feasting, Christendom Still Exists!

What is a perennial truth if nothing other than a truth which springs up every year?

We who are strangers and sojourners in the city of man, we who aspire towards citizenship in the city of God, we know that Christmas is all about celebrating Christ’s birth.

All of Christian literature, all of the literature that celebrates or dimly shadows Christendom stands in testimony that Christendom is the Feast! Search your Homer. Search your Virgil. Sit with Beowulf at the mead-benches in Hrothgar’s Heorot or with Gawain at the halls of Arthur or King Bertilak. All of us, pilgrims proceeding to Canterbury know that our pilgrimage begins and ends with feasting!

The culmination of Christendom is centered around the sacrum convivium, the sacred feast in which Christ Himself is ultimately consumed!

img_20191225_150007.jpg

Image result for medieval christ in the manger christmas

And when we feast we do everything we can to carry out and reproduce all the beautiful traditions that we have grown up with, the traditions of our parents and grandparents and those we have gathered from others through marriage or simply emulation.

Image result for christmas feast medieval

Catholic civilization, Christendom, is, among other things, a sort of fabric composed of all that is good, true, and beautiful-all these things woven into a single cloth- not a quilt-but an integral cloth, an exquisite tapestry!

img_1459.jpg

Of course, all the externals, all the things visible to the outward eye and senses are something just shy of sacramentals in that they betoken the inward realities of the exercise of Christ’s grace and His workings in our own minds and hearts.

Sure, at the present time,  Christendom might appear to have disappeared from view, nonetheless, it lives with vigor and vibrancy in the hearts of all those who celebrate Christmas with feasting!

Image result for midnight Mass

This year we commenced our Christmas Day celebration at about 2:30 pm with brunch.

Why so late?

Well – the late Christmas-day brunch is a common theme among Catholic clergy, organists, musicians, choristers, trumpet players, timpanists and anyone who volunteered his or her services at vigil Masses and Midnight Masses and early morning Masses and mid-morning Masses and noon Masses throughout the world.

And so it was with our family. Given that our last Mass was at noon on Christmas Day what a joy it was to return home and see the table set and ready for action!

bty

Every year we have an army of these little creamy baby Jesus buns

img_1467

baked to a golden brown!

img_1473bty

It could be that those of you who inhabit the warmer and more temperate climes of this country are used to the bright colors of a fresh fruit salad. But until you have lived in the colder northern regions of this earth, you cannot have experienced the full joy of bright ruby raspberries, sunny pineapple and mild mango in the winter!

btyimg-3521.jpg

Pears and pomegranates both of which symbolize eternal life make an appropriate centerpiece for any brunch table!

img-3522.jpg

I don’t know what mimosas symbolize if nothing other than the effervescent emotions that bubble over on Christmas day.

img_1490

We needn’t look for symbolism in every food that is appropriate for Christmas Brunch. But I loved this dish of diced fried potatoes.

img_1474

Though the cell phone camera is not able to catch the moist scrumptiousness of the cheesy egg sausage Strata, I can assure you that it was indeed cheesy moist and scrumptious.

img_1476img_1485

img_1486

img_1478-e1577420182758.jpg

I think the empty strata dish stands in testimony to my former statement. Q.E.D.!

img_1492

You might wonder how anyone who partakes of an afternoon brunch can think of a Christmas dinner! But there are roughly six hours between a 2:30 brunch and a 9pm dinner. While the chefs were at work the rest of us could spend our time gazing at the tree with a sort of misty gratitude for brunch as well as a joyful expectation of the future feast.

IMG-3510

This year we opted for the boneless Ribeye USDA roast. Here she is ready to go into the 500-degree oven for 25 minutes marinated in a pound of butter and minced garlic

20191225_183327

Meanwhile, Mary began preparing the mushroom sauce!

20191225_183149

The mushroom concoction consisted of the mushrooms mixed with wine, balsamic vinegar and the juices from the Ribeye.

As the dinner table was prepared, the chefs refreshed themselves with a chilled Riesling,

img_1498

while the bystanders had a small tasting of the Laphroaig Single Malt Scotch that one fortunate member of our company received in his stocking.

img_1495

Another army of soft yeasted dinner rolls magically prepared themselves to enter the oven while the roast was resting.

img_1500

img_1513-e1577420287271.jpgimg_1525

At last, with appetites rested and renewed for the attack, dinner is served.

img_1532

img-3541-e1577420000697.jpg

20191225_230135

No Christmas is complete without the Enstrom Toffee that my father sends every year!

img_1551

Merry Christmas!

Image result for christ child medieval

Posted in breakfast, Christendom, Christmas, Dinner, Feasts, Virgil | Tagged , , , , | 5 Comments

Why Would Anyone Eat Locusts and Wild Honey?

Wearing a camel-hair garment and a leather belt is one thing but eating locusts and wild honey is another!

I don’t suppose John the Baptist was wearing the camel hair garment that I am familiar with – although I think it would certainly have given an ecumenical advantage with the Brooks Brothers crowd – of whom I have been a sometimes admirer!

Image result for camel hair jacket

No, the intent of the gospel writers-particularly St. Matthew and Saint Mark-was clear. John was clearly eschewing the comfortable garments of the rich and was purposely wearing some incredibly uncomfortable garment like the one this artist imagined.

Image result for camel hair john baptist

But as if that wasn’t enough of a mortification let’s focus a little on his diet!

Here is what St Matthew wrote which, incidentally, my rudimentary knowledge from teaching elementary Greek to high school students has given me just enough facility to handle.

ἡ δὲ τροφὴ ἦν αὐτοῦ ἀκρίδες καὶ μέλι ἄγριον.

My translation:

And the food/nourishment/maintenance (τροφὴ) was of him (αὐτοῦ) locusts (ἀκρίς, ίδος, ἡ) and wild (ἄγριον) honey (μέλι, ιτος, τό)

Or I suppose one might say,

And his food was locusts and wild honey.

The Douay Rheims gets a little creative when it translates the same verse from Latin,

esca autem ejus erat locustæ, et mel silvestre

rendering it thusly,

and his meat was locusts and wild honey.

I suppose locusts or grasshoppers might be meaty underneath those brittle exoskeletons. Yuck!

Image result for locust close up

Now back to the question. We all know that scripture is the word of God and therefore we need to take every word seriously.

But remember! We need to start with the literal sense of the words (in scripture) before we proceed to any spiritual signification. So, the bottom line here-the literal sense is that- yes, John the Baptist actually appears to have eaten locusts and wild honey. The Greek and the Latin are just too clear. Besides, we also have this solid well-substantiated and irrefutable evidence from Wikipedia concerning the eating of locusts!

They are also edible insects; they have been eaten throughout history and are considered a delicacy in many countries.

Image result for locusts edible

Yum!

I am completely convinced.

So, let’s move on from the literal meaning. We need not entertain further any notion that the locusts that John the Baptist ate were really something else – like Locust Bean Gum extracted from the seeds of the carob tree!

Carob Tree, Ceratonia siliqua, Tree Seeds (Edible, Evergreen) - Picture 1 of 11

No! St. Matthew and St. Mark were perfectly aware that they were relating something that would shock their readers. They knew that anyone hearing about John’s diet would probably be impressed at the strength of his resolution- despite any considerations concerning just how scrumptious locusts might be. Besides, no reader is really interested in carob trees! Pshaw!

The literal meaning of the verse is clear. Let us proceed to the even meatier spiritual senses.

And to what source do we turn when we wish to plummet the depths of the Gospel a little more deeply?

Why – St. Thomas’ Catena Aurea of course!

As usual St. Thomas is too kind to satiate our appetites with locusts. Instead, like the intellectual bee he was, he gathered up all the honey from the various fathers and doctors of the church and has spread it all out for us his students! (note well! that in the ‘flight’ of my poetic simile I did not compare you, my dear reader, to the drones back in the hive!)

Image result for wild honey bee hive

Listen to what St. Gregory says about this passage commenting on St. Mark’s  account,

…by the kind itself of his food he pointed out the Lord, of whom he was the forerunner; for in that our Lord took to Himself the sweetness of the barren Gentiles, he ate wild honey. In that He in His own person partly converted the Jews, He received locusts for His food, which suddenly leaping up, at once fall to the ground. For the Jews leaped up when they promised to fulfil the precepts of the Lord; but they fell to the ground, when …they affirmed that they had not heard them. They made therefore a leap upwards in words, and fell down by their actions.

In other words, John points to the Lord who came to earth in order to draw everyone unto Himself. This has a comparison to eating in which food is drawn into the one who eats and is, in fact, made to become one with the one who eats.

Another commentator, the blessed Theophylactus, the eleventh-century Byzantine exegete has this to say,

The food also of John not only denotes abstinence, but also shews forth the intellectual food, which the people then were eating, without understanding any thing lofty, but continually raising themselves on high, and again sinking to the earth. For such is the nature of locusts, leaping on high and again falling.

This reminds me of Our Lord’s answer to his disciples when they asked Him why he taught in parables,

Why speakest thou to them in parables? Who answered and said to them: Because to you it is given to know the mysteries of the kingdom of heaven: but to them it is not given…because seeing they see not, and hearing they hear not, neither do they understand.

Blessed Theophylactus continues,

In the same way the people ate honey, which had come from bees, that is, from the prophets; it was not however domestic, but wild, for the Jews had the Scriptures, which are as honey, but did not rightly understand them.

It appears to me that Blessed Theophylactus is comparing the prophets to bees, which seems like an apt comparison. Bees go busily about, sometimes stinging people, but ultimately their work is to bring sweetness and honey!

Image result for honey bee

But insofar as the “honey” of the scriptures is not understood – it is foreign and therefore is wild. In other words, Theophylactus is saying that this wild honey- the scripture misunderstood by the Jews, was the food of John the Baptist.

So, of course, John the Baptist ate locusts and wild honey! What else would he eat?

Posted in Advent, Aquinas, Catena Aurea | Tagged , , , | 18 Comments

Still Thankful After All These Years

Grace builds upon nature. Or as we classically educated Latin teachers would construe,

Gratia Supponit Naturam

or even “Gratia aedificat super naturam”?

In any case, whether George Washington was stirred by the Holy Ghost, when he rendered his first Thanksgiving Proclamation, or whether he was simply following right reason and the natural law – none of this matters insofar as the effect is in profound sympathy with the spirit of Christianity.

Image result for washington thanksgiving proclamation

The central attitude of the Christian is one of thanksgiving. After all, isn’t that what the very word “Eucharist” means? Those who follow nature and show gratitude, by setting aside time from work for resting and for communal feasting, are essentially driven by a primordial impulse which has its ultimate completion in Holy Mass. As Saint Paul says,

For now we see now through a glass, darkly

And Thanksgiving Day is just such a glass- although I would include it among the clearer glasses through which we might gain a glimpse of the Divine.

I certainly gained a glimpse of the divine when I beheld the morning preparations for the feast. We traditionally eat a bit later- about 7pm. This is a tradition that developed because of the limited capacity of our dual fuel oven.

For all its virtues, the problem with this oven is that the narrow electric side oven is incapable of holding any ordinary baking or roasting dish- except for perhaps those who cook lots of meatloaves. Consequently, the main gas oven is the only thing workable for cooking pies and of course the turkey. But with a 30lb Turkey roasting for at least 4.5-5 hours, the pies and anything else that needs to be baked necessarily monopolized the oven for the greater part of the morning. Hence, we generally eat on the later side.

And so while the bakers inserted a succession of what turned out to be ten pies into the oven, the chefs commenced to build the assortment of necessary side dishes on the stovetop. First, they began with a spinach-beet-feta cheese concoction.

20191128_143627

After the cranberries had simmered down to a jelly-like consistency they were cooled and garnished with orange shavings.

20191128_172027

Third, the stuffing – an assortment of celery and onions were cooked until tender and subsequently mixed with sourdough bread crumbs and a special mix of savory herbs!

20191128_143642

Even when a bit blurry, these buttery caramelized shallots are one of my favorites.

20191128_172056

Meanwhile, as an aperitif, I uncorked a bottle of Vouvray and served it with a small army of cheeses to keep the chefs (and hangers-around) energized.

20191128_143733

This little dish- cranberry, celery, and a little lemon zest provided a cold chutney of sorts to provide a cooling contrast to the other dishes.

20191128_144146

Not pictured are the creamed peas and pearl onions nor the beets and spinach inebriated with a balsamic reduction, not to mention the traditional sides of mashed potatoes, sweet potatoes, gravy, and, of course, the turkey!

Finally, dinner was served…children and cousins first!

20191128_181445

Then the adults.

IMG-3202

In addition to other sparkling beverages, for the wine, we decided on a couple bottles of Cotes du Rhone thinking that these would make the best stand against the cranberry sauce.

img-3223-e1575133448397.jpg

img-3217-e1575132989272.jpg

Finally the pies! My favorite-the pecan! But I always try to hide a piece of apple for breakfast.img-3200-e1575133515792.jpg

IMG-3227

Posted in Custom, Feasts, Fine Arts, Saint Paul, The Mass | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

St. John Henry Newman and the Scandal of Catholic Classical Education

Saint John Henry Newman, speaking of the unique status of Western Civilization in the history of the world, emphatically asserts,

I think it has a claim to be considered as the representative Society and Civilization of the human race, as its perfect result and limit…I call then this commonwealth preeminently and emphatically Human Society, and its intellect the Human mind, and its decisions the sense of mankind, and its disciplined and cultivated state Civilization in the abstract, and the territory on which it lies the Orbis Terrarum, or the World.

Now if it wasn’t for the fact that this Cardinal was just canonized, I think we could all brush this statement off as an overly zealous defense of Western Civilization. After all, sometimes people get carried away and say things that they don’t really mean. For example, I will often say things like,

I think 100% arabica coffee beans may be considered as the representative coffee bean of civilization and of the human race. Nay even the preeminent coffee bean and even the bean in virtue of which all other beans merit the name “coffee bean.”

To the extent that other beans measure up or fall away from the arabica bean, that is the exact measure in which each bean may be called a coffee bean.

Or perhaps about the music of Mozart,

I think it has a claim to be considered as the representative music of the human race, as its perfect result and limit…I call then this music preeminently and emphatically Human Music, and the mind of Mozart is par-excellence the musical mind!

Mozart’s music is the music of mankind and in the abstract, his music and the territory in which it is heard is the Orbis Terrarum, or the World.

Ha! That is a wonderful statement.

Related image

I love the bravado. And what’s more, I completely agree with it.

As a matter of fact- with apologies to Newman, I think I will lay claim to this statement as being perhaps the very clearest statement ever made about the worth and value of Mozart’s musical contributions.

Did you ever hear him praised more highly?

I think not!

In the future, I plan on making a similar statement about Shakespeare so prepare yourselves.

But in the meantime let me return to the Blessed John Henry Cardinal Newman and his statement about Western Civilization.

Can there be a clearer or more forceful statement about the value of Western Civilization that flies more in the face of the current attitude of cultural relativism?

My old teacher Dr. Jack Neumayr, a philosopher and professor at Thomas Aquinas College, commenting on Newman’s statement writes:

Some who regard all culture as empirical, as we have seen, will defend liberal education because it is good to know our origins; not that our culture is normative, but it is ours. Others will insist on the utility of knowing the roots of the good and evil in our society. Still others, thinking it well to know the works of man, urge us to scan the achievements of western thought. None, however, under the pressures of egalitarianism and skepticism, dares assert it is the measure of the human mind.

John W. Neumayr | Thomas Aquinas College

Indeed, few in our day see the value of liberal education so clearly. This education, which arises from western society, is none other than the education which is the measure of the human mind. It is the education that fulfills the nature of man; it is the education that disposes man for the life of grace.

Liberal education is a scandal to the modern world. Liberal education is a scandal because it presents itself in direct opposition to the prevalent educational philosophy of our day; it is a stumbling block to the aspirations and goals of modern education. Those goals include no more than what is thought necessary to equip the student with the particular knowledge that will further a specific career.

Liberal education …a boulder in the road of establishment educational philosophy! (Admittedly, that boulder is a little more than a “scandal”)

Thus liberal education is a scandal to modern ears for at least two reasons. It is a scandal to those who are themselves ‘proponents of liberal education’ for the wrong reasons; reasons that amount to no more than a sort of cultural relativism and ultimately deny that liberal education is the education for the human mind.

It is also a scandal to those who propose the purpose of education is to equip man for this world; for some career.

As Cardinal Newman writes elsewhere,

“This process of training, by which the intellect, instead of being formed or sacrificed to some particular or accidental purpose, some specific trade or profession, or study or science, is disciplined for its own sake, for the perception of its own proper object, and for its own highest culture, is called Liberal Education…”

Posted in education, liberal education, Mozart, Newman, truth for its own sake | Tagged , , , , , | 12 Comments