Stop Saying Health is a Common Good!

Has there ever been an epoch in human history in which greater service, more profound obeisance, deeper devotion has been paid to the very end and purpose of all creation- the common good?

University of St. Thomas : Life | LinkedIn

Or maybe not?

Let’s remind ourselves quickly about what the common good is.

God is the common good. God is that good which we can share with one another, whom we can possess, to whom we can unite ourselves, in whom we can particpate all without diminishing Him.

By way of contrast, when we share a box of ice cream it only goes so far. The more people that share it, the less there is for each. But the common good is a good that can be shared without diminution.

Kroger - Kroger® Deluxe Death By Chocolate Ice Cream, 48 fl oz

Teach Your Kids About Taxes, Eat 30% Of Their Ice Cream - NestEggRx

Another interesting thing about the common good is that it is common.

The ice cream you eat is not common. Your ice cream is not my ice cream even if it came from the same box. Not so when we “share” God. Even when shared, God remains common to all. The God that I possess in Holy Communion is none other than the God that every Christian possesses.

In recent months we have been asked to make sacrifices for the common good. Out of an abundance of caution and for the common good are ubiquitous phrases which immediately signal the unpleasant reality that something will be imminently discontinued, like free samples at Costco, or that something will be denied like public attendance at Holy Mass.

If you go to Costco for the free food samples you will be ...

The archdiocese of Chicago, like most dioceses throughout the country cancelled public attendance at Masses invoking the common good, saying,

…we make this sacrifice for the common good, convinced that we, like all citizens, have a responsibility in preventing the spread of COVID-19.

Bishop Zubick of the Pittsburg Diocese even invoked the common good in reference to the curtailing of Lenten fish fries! He said,

[I] trust that the leadership of every parish is going to make a decision based on what’s important for the common good.

I don’t know about you, but I have been programmed to follow any order, any prescription, any injunction no matter how drastic or demanding just as long as the words “for the common good” are contained somewhere in the injunction.

If you said to me.

“Langley, we need you jump out of the airplane with no parachute…for the common good!”

Jumping out of a plane, SR-40 | free download photo

Well then, I would count myself a coward of no worth whatsoever to refuse! It’s like those Austrailian soldiers at Gallipoli. When the whistle blew they all leapt up out of the trenches into the very teeth of enemy Gatling guns.

Machine Gun - Terrifying Weapons of War

They all knew, every last one of them, that stepping out of trench would gain them each an almost instantaneous death. When that whistle blew, did they hesitate? Did they refuse?

No! Each one of them leapt up and died knowing (at least he thought he knew) he was fighting and dying for the common good. Regardless of what one may think about whether World War I was waged for just reasons, at least those lowly Australian soliders were convinced that in dying they were going to merit a hero’s reward. And I think they did!

File:Soldiers in trench.jpg - Wikimedia Commons

But the point we are currently making, is that when one is ordered to do something for the common good, every valiant soul who has the courage of one of those soliders at Gallipoli, or who is as brave as one of those 300 Spartan Hoplites at Thermopylae (commanded by the fearless King Leonidas in 480 BC),

Amazon.com: KING LEONIDAS OF SPARTA HERO MILITARY WARRIOR ...

every such a one, I say, would leap to the task at hand no matter how unpleasant, and strive to accomplish it with might and main…but mostly because it is all to be done for the common good!

Now when it comes to health we need to make a distinction. On the one hand, let us acknowledge that we all ought to be willing to take steps to protect our own health and the health of others.

Why?

Because health is a good thing. It’s good for people to be healthy.

But is health a common good? No. Health is a private good.

Human Goods and Moral Precepts - ppt download

Health is a good of the body and is distinctly particular to each person. One person’s health is no more another person’s health than is one person’s beauty the same as another person’s beauty. True, health is not diminished when more than one person has it. But neither does each person share the same health. Health is not shared; it is not common.

It could be that restrictions on liberty and requirements like ‘lockdowns,’ are sacrifices with which reasonable people might comply, at least for a time.

With quirks and restrictions, many states lift lockdowns

But when such requests are made under the guise that these things are required for the sake of the common good, then we overplay the force of the request and ultimately trivialize the common good. To invoke the common good is nothing more than to invoke the highest motivation for which any human being ought to act. But if that good is not the highest good, then it is right to ask questions about what we should sacrifice for it.

About marklangley

Academic Dean at The Lyceum (a school he founded in 2003, see theLyceum.org) Mark loves sacred music and Gregorian Chant and singing with his lovely wife, Stephanie, and their twelve children.
This entry was posted in America, Common Good, Herodotus and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Stop Saying Health is a Common Good!

  1. Ted T says:

    I think perhaps that you have conflated the notion of the common good with universal goods. Universal goods tend to be spiritual things such as justice mercy or God himself. But the notion of the common good refers to nations or states or polities. It’s a real thing. It’s worthy of serious consideration. The Catholic catechism defines it in terms such as those conditions leading to human flourishing of most of the citizens or the greatest number of the citizens. Probably when we think of the common good we should refer it to conditions of justice for everybody. I don’t think we should just say it’s not a real thing. Here is what Wikipedia the Oracle of Truth has to say on the issue of the common good.
    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Common_good

    • marklangley says:

      I didn’t mean to exclude common goods “by predication” as having any right to the name common good. If you want to say that 10 healthy men in a room are participating in a common good (i.e. health) then fine! But common goods by predication are the very weakest sense of the term. But we “philosophers” are more interested in the common good which is describes as “that good which is the foundation for the society of rational beings and the whole order of the universe, is a good common as a cause and potential whole” as the erudite Rev. Sebastian Walsh explains brilliantly in this essay. (https://thomasaquinas.edu/pdfs/aquinas-review/2013-14.pdf#page=9) But that the best… and ultimate…. and final… and most real sense of the word ‘common good’ is none other than God —-I stoutly maintain.

  2. Joseph R Gonzalez says:

    Health is not itself the common good (or at least, not common by causation), and for the same reasons you gave, life itself is not the common good (your life is not my life etc). So when the soldier is asked to lay down his life so that others may live, we say this is for the common good, not because the common good is life, but because the common good requires certain material goods for it to exist. You can, for example live a life of virtuous friendship in a political community, but you have to be living in the first place in order for this to be possible. So would you agree that life and health are, generally speaking, necessities that the common good requires? In other words, would you agree that saying we must do X for health safety reasons and that this is “for the common good” does not necessarily mean that health itself is the common good?

    • marklangley says:

      That is a fair point. As Ted said above referring to the CCC “By common good is to be understood the sum total of social conditions which allow people, either as groups or as individuals, to reach their fulfillment more fully and more easily.” (http://www.vatican.va/archive/ENG0015/_P6K.HTM)

      And so you rightly point out that health is something that can be ultimately related to the common good (i.e. certain things are before others in being as bricks are before a brick wall etc). In this case I would have to agree with your statement that ““for the common good” does not necessarily mean that health itself is the common good?”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s